Seeing how Faith was evil in season 3 and when she woke up from her coma in season 4 and was after Buffy and the Scooby Gang, I can totally see Faith casting the spell and making her own alternative reality and making everyone woworship her!

i would have to go with Faith. I also don't get what Loki has to do with Buffy as he wasn't in the show.

Or Willow. I think Andrew would be too similar to Jonathan's canon episode.

I don't see the point of the non-Buffy options in these clubs. They'd be unlikely to be possible, other than in something like fan fiction, because of copyright issues.

Sence Superstar is an alternative episode I thought it would be funny if Loki was the one who made everyone worship him! That's totally something Loki would do! If Loki was in this episode we might even get to see Thor and the other Avengers fight with Buffy to kick Loki's ass!

Yes it would definitely be funny! Loki is awesome!