19. Jessica Rabbit
18. Vanellope
17. Lilo
16. Melody
15. Maid Marian
14. Anita
13. Nani
12. Tinkerbell
11. Wendy
10. Alice

I hear so many people complain about how modern Disney movies ridicule the older ones, but Enchanted is the only one that really rubs me the wrong way with this. I just feel like Giselle is such a disrespectful parody of the original DPs, plus I don't like the idea of a primarily live-action character being a part of the lineup.

I don't really consider her royalty unlike some of the others.

^Jane is sort of queen of the jungle as Tarzan is king of the jungle, though.

Well, it's time for Giselle to go. I like her but she's definitely won't match the DP lineup as she's mostly appear as a live action character, she doesn't end up as a princess but a career woman instead, and also she's just a mix up of the classics + Ariel.

Like people have mentioned, Giselle was made be a parody of the DPs and mock them, and I really don’t see something like that fitting in the lineup.

Same reasons as before. Jane isn't a princess.

She may be a princess, but the others are more interesting.

Well, I read in the wiki that she's twelve, so she's too young, imo. Not even a teen. But Giselle is also a good pick, due to being part live-action.

Either her (too young) or Giselle imo.

She and Kida are not popular in my country.

I love her but she's technically not even really a princess. Plus, she's live-action for most of the film. Also, Eilonwy isn't too young. She's the same age as Snow White, which is 14.

What's wrong about Giselle being live-action? At least that part of her isn't a parody!

Anyway, I'm going with Eilonwy because the others just fit better.

Same as before. The ones who openly ridicule the DP lineup for "falling in love" too early, or claim "not to be a princess" SHOULD definitely NOT be in the lineup.

That means, no Elsa, no Moana, no Giselle.

Next will go esmeralda.

Now we're getting down to the ones that make sense to include.
Of course, the current lineup is fine the way it is.

I don't think that just being a parody or supposedly "ridiculing" the Disney Princesses is something that can keep someone out of the line-up because Merida was literally meant to basically be a middle finger to the Disney Princesses. Brenda Chapman even confirmed that Merida was supposed to be the anti-Disney Princess. So everyone here should not be using that as a reason for others not to be included.

The people using the argument that Jane or Giselle are not princesses so they shouldn't count sound ridiculous because most of them support Mulan being in the DP franchise and in fact love her inclusion. If anything, adding a non princess to the lineup strengthens Mulan's claim to the lineup. Also Disney Wiki says Eilonwy is 12. She and Taran were modeled after younger characters like Mowgli so that age is more believable than her being a teen.

You do realize that literally anyone can edit the Disney Wiki page, so it's not reliable. Also, Mulan can be considered kind of above royalty because royalty felt the need to bow down to her, as well as had all of China bow down to her. So that can explain her reason for being in the line-up, aside from just wanting to add diversity. Jane can be considered royalty because she's married to the King of the Jungle, therefore making her Queen.

Except that Eilonwy is two years younger than Taran and Taran clearly isn't 16 and probably not even 15. He's on the younger side, so by extension, Eilonwy would be younger than him. Above royalty still doesn't equate royalty. One could argue that a president or prime minister or even god is higher than royalty but that doesn't give them a Royal status. Ergo, Mulan is not a princess. Being the hero of China is a moot point. The real point is that the DP line clearly isn't restricted to princesses so arguing that someone is not a princess is nonsensical. Especially since Giselle is not a princess and she was confirmed to have been a part of the franchise had it not been for the issue with paying Amy Adam's for using her likeness.

@KL: You have your reason for inclusion/exclusion. I have mine. I will continue to say that "ridiculing" a princess for falling in love too early doesn't seem fair--- and is a reason to exclude Elsa. I also will say that Mulan never had to let loose a line "I am not a princess!" in her own movie--- and starting with Tiana, nearly all of the "princesses" besides Rapunzel have done so. I am tired of hearing "the would-be-princess say "I am not a princess!" It's annoying and trite.

So I exclude based on "falling in love" being used as a form of "shaming," and hearing the same stupid line over and over.

Disney forced Merida into the lineup to make up for the fact that it was a PIXAR movie, and because Disney thought PIXAR was their holy grail before Frozen became a phenomenon. Sure. You can decide that "ridicule" isn't deserved for excluding something. But don't ask me to vote any differently than I do.

^and let's not forget that even live-action Belle disses being called a princess.

I'm curious though wavesurf, how you feel about Enchanted and Giselle? Do you feel that it was also a parody of classic Disney tropes the way Frozen is?

^YUP. I don't like that movie, either. I don't have any Giselle stuff, just like I don't have any Elsa stuff, because I absolutely loathe what Elsa said to Anna about romance.

Elsa had a lot of *um, nerve* calling out her sister for "racing into a romance," when she blocked her sister out of her life for years at the advice of stupid parents--- but the first real instruction Elsa gives her sister is---- "You can't marry a man you just met!" I find it ironic that you've sat in a room for the last ten or twenty years avoiding ALL people, not just men. And the first thing about life you say to your sister is --- avoid a man you just met.

Plus, Disney made Hans the skeaviest, EASIEST douchebag to spot in a million years--- because if Elsa had said that about "a Prince Phillip or Prince Eric-like character," the whole thing would have made her look like a loon.

As I said, I don't love when Disney opts to "diss me" with their pandering to an audience that loves to "ridicule characters." Parodies have their place, but Frozen is SATIRE, just the way Enchanted is. In my opinion, unless Disney Incorp. intends to scrap what Walt Disney gave us in Snow White and Cinderella, they better not put in Elsa.

She is the least popular princess, save for Tiana, in my country. So naturally, I see no purpose for her in the lineup.

Elsa best

Too much live action