I really thought more of her... Sue never made her do anything. She chose to do it

For once, I actually sided with Mr. Shue! I did think it was a little unfair to only kick Sanatana out and not Brittany. I get that she's not that smart and probably had no idea what's going on half the time... but still

Well Brittany didn't actually participate with them when they burned the piano

Actually, she didn't put gasoline on the piano. The other cheerleaders did. She just stayed all the time behind Blaine dancing.

Also, they JUST put gasoline on the piano. It was Quinn who threw the cigarette on the piano making it lit up.

I just think that Will is a douche and should not even teach in this school. He isn't a good role model for the kids & we has preferences - it is shown throughout the whole series.

I think i saw Santana putting gasoline on the piano too

Please illuminate me and tell me which time it is so I will go and look it all over again. I just, if you notice she is all the time behind Blaine. I thought she was putting gasoline at first, but after the second time I rewatched it, she is not there.

&& still, Will saying he will let Sugar join Glee club because she tried [even though she doesn't know how to sing and everything *although I got to say that I am in love with her character already*] & then he just kicks Santana out because of a fight he started with Sue. I just find it hypocritical.

You are absolutely right. I just saw a black ponytail and assumed it was Santana.

And i think Will was kinda pressured by Rach. If he wants to win Nationals he has to have the best vocals there are. Or atleast someone who is not tone deaf. Kicking Santana out was a question of loyalty. He can't risk Santna pulling a stunt like this during Sectionals or Nationals. And be honest, if you were in a club and one person is ruining it and your spirits.. Wouldn't you want this person to leave?

I don't know, I get why he did it but I was still kind of mad at him; for one there's NOTHING to prove that Santana definitely did it and as much as I love Quinn it was her who threw the cigarette it seems so unfair to just kick Santana out without even having proof that she did it, plus she's a high schooler, as a teacher he should be aware that what your peers think of you and popularity is important to alot of kids, especially for Santana because it's like her identity and her guard he really should bear in mind that it's not at all easy to just say "no! I don't care what everyone thinks i'm staying loyal to my club." it's much easier said than done, I just think he was really harsh on her. Also what happened to innocent until proven guilty!?

I am sorry for keep replying but I am still mad at him for doing this just to Santana. Brittany sabotaged the whole Glee club multiple times before and he never kicked her out. Quinn and Santana did the same in the past, but nothing happened either.

Also, it might have been that Rachel pressured him, but she pressured him not to add Sugar to the team [Gawd, I am feeling bad to say bad things about Sugar] but he still went and talked to her and told her she is welcome in the club.

Again, I just think that Will does whatever he wants to, he is a hypocrite and I just am hating his character more and more with time passing.

the only thing i would of done different is not in front of everyone i would of talked to her privetly then told everyone with her not in the room

i think that will is getting more and more tired of santana, brittney and quinn sabotogeing the glee club, and he had it quinn wasn't in glee club anymore, brittney didn't light the piano on fire santana did

I think he might've jumped to a conclusion at first until she fessed up with the "sue made me do it" line. It wasn't out of context either, she knew exactly what he was referring to, and therefor I would have kicked her out the door just as fast.

Double dealing is one thing, but you can't destroy school property and deliberately sabotage your own extracurricular club and expect not to be punished for it.

Santana was dancing with Blaine and the other Cheerios. And if you rewind, she wasn't the one with the cigarette. That'll give you a clue on who did it or not. Please, bring Santana back and don't do her wrong again!!!

^She didn't have to do anything since the piano was already doused in some kind of flammable liquid that she probably applied earlier before that whole number took place. Nothing ignites that fast without some kind of lighter fluid or flammable substance, all it took was one cigarette (flicked by Quinn) to do the rest of the work.

Okay, you're saying all this but just watch the show. You know it is Glee right? It is not actually that fact-y.

When the cheerleaders are pouring gasoline on the piano, she is not there. If she poured some flammable liquid beforehand, I think it would have been quite difficult for the guy playing the piano to actually play it that good...

Also, you're saying that she did this and that beforehand but you never actually saw it. Just like Will. You're just assuming she did it because she said she is Team Sue. Just, one last thing for now. She chose Team Sue to protect herself. Sue knows that she's gay because of how she posed the question, Santana understood it & feeling threatened, she chose Sue's team.

What is with this?!?!?!? Quinn threw the ciggy that lit it on fire

Wow! Who cares? She lit a piano on fire. Big deal! She's amazing and Will kinda sucks in my opinion. She shouldn't be kicked out!

^^ Wow. Biased much?