in my opinion, its definitely hp. twilight is a lame romantic novel with a stupid storyline. Weve seen too many of them.

the twilight hype will be over in a few years time
people will come to their senses and realise what a lameass book it is

both will be epic forever-they are both THAT great!

harry potter definetly

Twilight's good, but so many people are crazy over it now that it will run out of awsomeness eventually... I mean it's already starting too lose its POW! As with Harry Potter people like it but they're not crazy over it and it all didn't happen at once.

Even though I prefer Twilight, I definately think HP.

hp is getting an island in islands of adventure, its impossible for it not to become an epic after that!

i'm a fan of both saga...and honestly i said that...hp will b remain epic...i'm agree with weasleyismyking....

Thank god HP won. I might of flipped out if Twilight did. Of course people will realise what a load of crap Twilight is and it will be forgotten, eventually. But Harry Potter will live on.

While Twilight might not blow over like I would like it to, it will never be as popular as HP. I honestly think that HP is a classic. It's so well-written and interesting and it has such good, strong morals that really make you think. What else makes a good classic, if not that?

Twilight isn't a very original story. The reason Harry Potter will last for generations to come is because it's such an amazing, fantastic world which inspires children and adults alike. It's something so special it'll never be forgotten. Twilight will blow over in within the next 10 years.

Bloody hell! Who picked Twilight?!

No one who picked Twilight explained their response ... I wonder why ... *rolls eyes* because, maybe, it won't exist.

twilight is just a fad its dieing out as we speak harry potter has been here for years and i plan to read it to my children (if i have any, because unlike bella im going to wait until im old enough to have them) as a bedtime story.

Obviously. Harry Potter's been around for how many years? It's the Chronicles of Narnia of its day. Twilight has material from other original work, which makes it unoriginal.

I thought it was obvious, HARRY POTTER ALL THE WAY!!

Everybody knows Harry Potter, Twilight not everyone

For me.
It depends on who you are, what you like, and how much you lie it, since "epic" is now a subjective term.