sirius

sirius always wins. even though lupin is awesome too

Remus all the way:D. will never like Sirius. he is way overrated.

I love both, but Lupin more :D

Always preferred him. ^^

Sirius is my favorite & Remus is my second favorite! :P

AHHHH this was soo hard cuz i FLOVE both!!! but since lupin is winning and i think im a bit in love with sirius just a bit more, than him <3

Remmy, I have a place in my heart for Remus. He's in my top 5 favs I think. Something about him... I love Remus!

Sirius is my favorite animagus :)

They're both amazing characters, but I always thought Sirius was a bit selfish. He treated Harry a bit too much like he was James. I totally agreed with Molly in the fifth book when she took a stand and told Sirius that Harry isn't James! Remus was always there for Harry, though.

^loll yea but thats another reason i love sirius. i mean of course he loved harry, but his undying love for his best friend is a bit heartbraking. and he was there for harry thru and thru too.

I Like both but Sirius a little more.

^^Agree with LoveDraco123. I think that even though he lloved to have a kind of his best friend but still.... I didn't think he ever really saw him as his own person. I also think that Lupin had to deal with much more, with the whole werewolf thing and he still turned out to be a good guy :D