link

I'm definitely thinking Belle for some reason, it kind of makes sense...second choice would be either Hook or Neal.

Next guess would be Hook.

or belle

To 'make room' for Captain Swan. :/ Would make sense to me. As long as it's not Gina, I'm cool.

For me as long as it's not Regina, Neal or David I'll be cool. Yes, the writers have to go for either CS or SF. I have seen CS fans give death threats to people before, wouldn't be surprised if they went with that. ^

Or Neal or Hook. I don't know I have a feel it would be one of the three of them.

Yup, same. ^

Or may be none of those, may be it's another character that will have a major role in the next half of season 3 (Like Robin Hood, Mulan or WW may be ?)

No, it's one of these ones (read the link I gave) these are the only possibilities. ^

Yeah I know I've read it, but I still think there are more possibilities, like remember the time when a spoiler came out that some members of the cast were filming at a church and it was a beloved/main character's funeral ? No one expected that character would be Blue, everyone thought it was one of those listed above

I was torn between David, Snow, Neal, Belle, and Hook..

I don't think it's David because he almost died, but he was saved. So I don't know why they would kill him now. Especially since Snow may get prego again.

I don't think it's Snow because...it's Snow. But maybe her pregnancy is causing her to have second thoughts about staying on the show. Who knows? It still wouldn't work well though because Emma hasn't had too much of a chance to really reconnect with Snow. Or David, either. So that's another point for him.

I was thinking it may be Belle, but why would they "kill" Rumple, (probably) bring him back, let them be happy, and then kill her off? Unless she feels like she has to one-up Rumple's sacrifice..lol. But it just doesn't make sense to me and I can't see why they'd kill her off. Unless she wants out.

So then it came down to Hook and Neal. I'd hate to see either of them go. I'm still torn between them, but I'm leaning towards Neal being the one to die. And no, it has nothing to do with my ship. I'm just looking at it from a stand point of character development. They haven't done a whole lot with Neal, even though they could have. Not much character development or big scenes... I could just see it being more likely with him. Which would actually be disappointing. I'd like to see Neal develop and find a happy ending (though not with Emma, lol). Plus, it would likely make it harder for CaptainSwan. I'd rather not see either of them go, though. So I'm hoping it's someone else. Like Henry. But I have a distinct feeling that won't happen.

or Neal to end the triangle would be my first guess, but the link gave a really good reason for Belle, too. I'd be really sad to see any of these three go, though :(

Blue was listed ^^

It's kind of obvious now that they said they're making a Neverland spin-off. It means that they'll have to kill off Hook so that he can become a main character in the spin-off! So I have to say HALLELUJAH UNNECESSARY SPIN-OFF! GOODBYE CAPTAIN SWAN AND HELLO SWANFIRE!

I thought Henry. His death could turn over the story. And to be honest, his role in ended. Of course everybody love him and everybody will mourn him but he's not so important character anymore.

They've already had Henry almost die twice, I don't think they's be that repetitive.

Maybe Belle or Neal

He just seems the most likely to me. Though I wish it would be Charming...or Snow.

Seriously, idk... But please, not Neal T_T

Because he's not important :D I just want Gold back...

Or Hook or Belle

God, some fans are so rude and inconsiderate. It truly bothers me because I can only imagine what kind of person they are beyond Fanpop and I can only wonder if it truly makes them happy to put people down or kick them while they're down.

If CaptainSwan were to really happen, I wouldn't mock Swanfire fans or rub the salt in their wounds by bragging. Because I, unlike some people apparently, am a decent human being. I know that if it were me and if things were the other way around, it wouldn't feel nice to have someone going "HA HA Swanfire wins! Hope you're having fun while your stupid CaptainSwan sinks!". Sure, it's just a show and it doesn't really affect my life, but we have invested a certain amount of time and emotion into our ships and it does suck when it sinks. And no one wants a jackass mocking them while they go down.

Pardon my french.

Oh man I love all these characters ,I would hate if any of them died . I refuse to pick because i simply have no idea but why does it have to be about the triangle again? and Neal&Hook having the most votes in the pick ? Neal/Emma or Hook/Emma (whichever is endgame) can be together without having the other character dying.

Okay, I just want for everyone to stop dying!! haha. I mean, even if I don't like the character some characters I like will suffer... Now, I think Neal is the most likely posibility cuz:
1. He's made up by the show, not an iconic disney character so the disney franchise wouldn't mind.
2. It would end the love triangle.
3. He hasn't received as much importance or development this season.
4. If they killed Hook to end the triangle they would risk loosing viewers cuz he's much more popular.
But... a reason to not think it'll be him is that they shot him lately and everyone thought he was dead so tying to kill him again would be a little repetitive. In that sense I think it could be Belle cuz they haven't tried to kill her off before (I think).

Points I would like to add to yours :) ^

2. It could be Hook to end the love triangle, not just Neal, the show wouldn't lose that many viewers. Maybe even Emma lol :P
3. Even more reason to keep him
Yeah and like you said they've already "killed" him, it would be pointless to do it again. ^

^Yeah, it would:) It could be Hook as well. Oh, Emma.. I hadn't even thought about that posibility lol... I doubt it though cuz she's really the main character.

She's not the main character, she's the main main character lol. All of these are the main characters but it centers around her. :P

I wouldn't be surprised if it was Neal because my list is:
5. Cora
4. August
3. Neal
2. Regina
1. Ruby
Cora died in 2x16, then August died (in a way; no longer an adult) so looks like it's Neal's turn :/

I was rather disappointed when they turned August into a boy. On one hand, looking at it now, it prevented things from getting too complicated. But it was a bummer. That and he was given a clean slate, which is kind of unfair because so many other characters don't get that opportunity. lol.

I count August as dead, because he is no longer and adult. Pinocchio isn't my 4th fave, August is :(

They said it would be a popular major character and Neal really isn't that popular. Besides they already played the whole Neal is dead card not too long ago so they shouldn't keep beating a dead horse. It's not like they had a problem killing iconic Disney characters when they killed Gus and Maid Marian or iconic characters in general when they killed Jack. So just because Hook is an iconic Disney character is not going to be enough to keep him alive. Neal has more potential because they have the whole mourning Rumple, though Belle will be doing a lot of that, but also showing sort of relationship between Belle and Neal in a family way since they've never gotten to really talk to each other or know each other. Neal probably still has some resentments towards his father and Belle is the person to help him understand, although still having resentments towards Rumple is also beating a dead horse.

Emma: She's the protagonist so to kill her off would just be stupid and too dark for them.

Regina: Unless they wanna lose ratings they won't kill her.

Snow White: They keep on going on about how her, Charming, and Emma will have their happily ever after together so it's unlikely that it will happen.

Charming: Same as Snow and the fact that they already used the whole almost dying thing so I doubt they'd use that again, it would be pointless.

Henry: I know for sure that he's safe! He's the character that holds the good guys (Emma, Charming, Snow, Neal) and the bad guys (Regina and Rumple). He's Regina and Emma's reason for living and the potential for when Regina and Henry meet each other again and all the feels, zanhar1 is going to crying herself a river. There's also the fact that they had him almost die twice, it would be quite repetitive and make him look like a damsel in distress and not his own character.

Belle: Rumple is coming back, we all know that because they're not stupid enough to kill who is probably the most popular character on the show. She's what makes Rumple want to be good. Plus the possibilities of Belle and Neal having a relationship, like a mother and son kind, is just amazing.

Neal: They already used the whole he died thing already, there's no need to beat a dead horse. Like I said, the possibilities of a mother and son relationship between him and Belle is just fantastic! Plus when him and Emma see each other again and all the feelings come back will just be amazing, along with him seeing Henry again. Plus, just like Belle, he's Rumple's reason for wanting to change.

Hook: They already bought him a tombstone when they said they were making a spin-off with Neverland. To give it potential they have to tell about him and his life on Neverland, along with Tinkerbell, Peter Pan, and Felix. Besides one dead horse the show seems to never get tired of is making Emma suffer from love so they'll probably have her get more feelings for him and later kill him off.

I don't think either of Henry's parents would die, because that would be pretty sad. Plus they already killed him (in a way, like Archie). They might kill Snow due to the fact Ginny's pregnant she might want a break. My top 3 choices are Belle, Neal and Hook for reasons listed above.

Either that or they'll just put her into a deep sleep, since she just wants "a break". They'll just have The Wicked Witch of The West do something to her to keep her away from the show. Something to that degree. I'm really hoping for Hook dying.

^ I dunno . I think they 'll make Snow pregnant on the show too ( well she already said she wanted a baby ) .

^Yeah, I think so too. That's what I'm hoping for, anyway!:D

Of course Neal would have the most votes -_- I really have no idea who could die...I kinda feel like it could be Regina, but I don't think she'll stay dead. I highly doubt it will be Neal. I mean Rumpel's already dead (even though it's debatable) who else could they possibly kill off?

Well in the link they made it clear the actor/tress wasn't coming back and the character is gone for good. ^

I think it's gotta be Neal...he's the only one with other projects other than OUAT going on currently. They really haven't done that much to develop his character, though they could have. My second pick would have to be Belle, unfortunately. She's my fav female character, but I could totally see it happening to hurt Rumple. Let's face it we all know he's not really dead. I really do not think it will be Hook, as the actor playing him moved his family from Ireland to Vancouver. You don't just do that if you're planning on picking up and leaving. Also, I wish everyone would stop talking about a Neverland spin off..Wonderland didn't even do that well.

Regina: Unless they wanna lose ratings they won't kill her.

Exactly, they better not try.

I hope it's henry...

unfortunately I think it's neal. he just seems least important to the story right now + they are trying to push captain swan so hard that there is no place for neal :(

Yup, that's true. CS fans sometimes go too far on Twitter from what I've seen tweeted to Adam things like "CS better happen or I quit the show!" "Swanfire is stupid, they better not happen!" so I wouldn't be surprised if they were too scared to make SF happen :/ ^

Rapunzel is black. (Sorry for the bluntness, I don't mean that in a derogatory way either)

I doubt they'd be afraid to go with SF instead of CS because of the fans if they weren't afraid to make such a drastic change like veering away from the traditional image of Rapunzel.

Besides, I've seen equally rude and childish comments from SF shippers.

...

I apologize if that sounded more aggressive than I meant it to be. It just bothers me to see so much CS bashing, though it's directed more towards the shippers. This is the OUaT fan page. All fans from all ships can see this, including CS, and it's like talking about someone to someone else while that person is standing right next to you. I'm not saying there aren't those CS shippers that say rude, immature, and childish things, but they aren't the only ones that say such things. Some SF shippers are at fault too.

I'm not bashing CS or it's fans, I'm just stating what I saw on Twitter. Sure you might have saw some SF shippers being rude, but I've not and I'm just saying that I saw CS fans being rude and threatening. Not bashing at all.

The bashing part wasn't necessarily directed towards you. That was just in general. Though bashing wasn't the right word, I just went with it for lack of a better term.

I don't like that CS shippers say such things and it gives a lot of us a bad rep (apparently) as well, so to see it being spread by others that witness it, doesn't help. It starts to seem like CS shippers really are just that bad. It feels like...I dunno...spreading a rumor.

No, better example. It's like saying all girls are shallow and all guys are cheaters. It's not true for either gender, but it seems like it when people start talking about this one guy or girl they know that fits the stereotype. The more we hear about it, the more it seems like it must be true. When in reality, only like 5% of the population is like that (I just made up a percentage, I really have no idea what an accurate number would be).

Am I making sense? I feel like I'm blabbering. I've been off all day.

I'm just aiming for a more equal setting. All ships have some bad eggs in them.

Now I hate Captain Swan even more because of the fans acting this way. Swanfire fans get out of control too but not nearly as bad as the Captain Swans do. They're threatening to quit the show just because of that. If they kill Neal and Captain Swan happens I won't stop loving the show but I will lose respect for choosing to go with a couple that is completely underdeveloped and is based only on sure attractiveness, the whole bad boy thing, and the fact that they're supposedly "kindred spirits". They have no chemistry and I will always hate them as a couple but it will not stop me from watching it if it happens so these twitter Captain Swan fans are just pathetic. You didn't see the Swan Queen fans stop watching the show when the creators said it will never happen.

I'm not saying all CS fans are like that at all (you are polite in the way you express opinions for example), but the ones I saw on Twitter were. Some CS fans on here are pretty polite, some aren't. Like you said about that you hate CS bashing, I feel the same way about SF bashing. I have even seen some fans saying they hope Neal dies just because he is a threat to CS being canon. ^^

@KataraLover- See? You're bunching up all of CaptainSwan into the same group. We're not all that bad. That's just what I want to stop. We're not all like that.

@Evilregal14- Yeah, I don't have a Twitter. lol. I try to avoid all of that. I've seen some really crazy and stupid Tweet screenshots. It is unfortunate that some CS shippers are like that. It makes me dislike being associated with them, but at the same time, I'm not. I'm my own person with my own actions (though not all are great) and just because I share an interest with them, doesn't mean I'm associated with them.

Me? Or KatarLover? ^

Fixed it. Sorry. XD

I've been personally insulted on Twitter for backing up Swanfire. You're right, it does give all fans a bad reputation, although i know not all are like that it does. I know that you specifically are not like that. ^

Did I say "all Captain Swan fans all like that"? No, I didn't! Just because I said Captain Swan fans it doesn't mean I'm talking about all of them but it is a majority of them. If you recall I did say that Swanfire fans can get out of control too but at least they don't send threats to Adam saying they'll quit watching the show.

@KataraLover- Calm down. I did not personally attack you. I apologize for misinterpreting your words, it seemed like you were putting all CaptainSwan shippers on the same boat. Also, they may not send threats on Twitter, but that doesn't mean the threats aren't being sent out. Neither ship is better than the other. If no threats are really being sent, then congrats. You win.

@Evilregal14- If those insulting you were CaptainSwan shippers, I apologize on behalf of CS. I know I'm just one voice among many, but no one deserves to be attacked for what they ship.

You don't need to apologize you've done nothing wrong. It was only a few of them anyway. Basically it started because i sent a tweet to Adam I think it was saying "I love Swanfire, I really hope they get together". A few CS fans who must have been friends were all saying that I was stupid for shipping them and that they would never be together. ^

@Evilregal14- That's ridiculous. It's all about perspective. You aren't stupid for shipping Swanfire. I can see why people do ship them. I just..can't because their relationship mirrors the relationship I had with my first love a few years ago. Not an exact mirror, I didn't end up pregnant or in jail and I had friends and family to catch me when I fell. But he broke up with me, out of nowhere. I thought everything was fine and turns out it wasn't. I went off the deep end a little and now, five years later, I'm still damaged. So my inability to ship Swanfire really stems from personal experience and actually, why I ship CaptainSwan stems from personal experience.

That's logical. Some CS fans have admitted shipping them because Hook is hot, which I find a bit silly. I didn't say anything though :P Yeah, one of them apologized to me but the other two just blocked me and I blocked them right back.

^ At least one apologized. But yeah, that is ridiculous (shipping CS because Colin is attractive). Because that means they would likely ship Swanfire if Colin played Neal instead of MRJ. Shallow people bother me. There's more to people than looks. Yes, Colin is attractive, but that has literally nothing to do with why I ship CaptainSwan. I just like a character that happens to be attractive, but why I like him doesn't have anything to do with his looks.

And how can it be enjoyable to like a person or character based on looks? If that's all there is, you can't truly appreciate the character beneath the skin. The personality. Their flaws, weaknesses, and strengths. It would be boring to like any character because "ohemgee gaiz he's so hawt".

Yeah, if I based characters on looks then I would love Hook and I don't. I personally think he is quite arrogant. And I personally think Neal is the exact opposite. ^

Now I don't even care of Neal dies, I prefer if Hook dies and I love Neal but I just want these stupid love triangle arguments to stop.

Glad I ship Fairy Queen, people tend to just ignore us. Which isn't bad in my opinion.

LUCKY YOU! I wish this love-triangle never existed!

I'm not big on love triangles either. The Avatar fandom handles them especially bad.

Neal...........

Neal.... :( :( :(