i would love it
but he's a bit young for her x x

Bethany Joy Lafferty, , bames? jethany? hum got a ring to it :P

Definetly!
James and Joy FTW!

THIS IS RIDICULOUS
THE FACT THAT MAKE A GOOD ON SCREEN COUPLE DOESN'T MEAN THAT THEY ARE GONNA BE A GOOD COUPLE IN REAL LIFE.
GET OVER IT PEOPLE!!

nah, I actually thought that Chad and Bethany were dating when headlines first surfaced a romance between chad & an actress on OTH. and I was disappointed when I learned it was indeed chad and sophia. so I always thought chad and bethany would make a good couple :) In fact, I think I'm gonna make a poll about it :D

Yeah they would make a cute couple, though i still want James & Sophia<33!

alessandra_28.
FYI.
Lucas and Brooke because a couple, in real life.
Theres always hope for other cast members. [:

Well, the chemistry's there bu let's face it. Their lives aren't a TV show. We don't know how they've been functioning backstage, and it's not up to us to decide who gets with whom in real life.
Plus that's kinda harsh on her actual husband.

You're forgetting the moral of the question.
it's just a what if question.
doesn't mean anything. :D

if she wasn't married, hell yeah :D
they're so sweet and the chemistry is awesome :)

Yes of course!!!! :)

I agree with the others who answeared the same. Just cause they're a couple on the show doesn't mean they would work out in real life. I mean they're different people irl then in the show. Plus I've heard James is dating Sophia.

.....If she wasn't already married.

naley are amazing onscreen together, but he is the youngest of the cast and she is the oldest...... the only people i loved being a couple ofscreen as well as onscreen was chad and sophia/ luke and brooke
:( :( :( :( :( :(

omg such a freakin stupid question.... ACTORS ARE PAID TO HAVE CHEMISTRY....dumb*

They'd be adorable together, and GJbeint I don't think age is that important, especially if there is only four years difference.
But I doubt it would happen because they are more like REALLY REALLY good friends then a romantic couple.
But had they been together in real life, that would have just been awesome.
But, on the other hand, I would have wanted them to wait until one tree hill was over because if something went wrong in their relationship, that could have seriously affected their on screen relationship.
But their chemistry is undeniable<3

And you can drop the attitude odette8, no one has done anything to deserve your negativity.

GJBeint, WHAT THE FUCK?! "naley are amazing onscreen together, but
he is the youngest of the cast and she is the oldest...... "
Do you think that matters?!?! does someone really believe
that????!!!!!
And acutally there isn't many years between them!!

BrookeYourself I agree with you! It's only 4 years!

I think people are so convinced of the Nate & Haley characters that the idea of them being a couple in real life is really easy to imagine. But I also think they their personalities are completely different to their characters so I think that they would be better friends and co-stars than as a true couple.

Don't think so.
Characters & actors are totally different story. Of course people who spend so much time together in work can get close, but I'm sooo far from thinking that all actors who play a good couple should try it in real life. That would mean that some actors should start a new relationship with every new movie/show.