I guess... Brooke was depressed & angry at the beginning of the season and sad, hurt, scared, and mellow toward the end of the season, so I can't say I loved season 6 Brooke as much as other seasons. But I don't think it's her worst season and I did find some of her story lines pretty interesting (and thought SB acted them out really well). Plus Brooke was my favorite thing about season 6, so I had to choose 6 over 4.

I also don't love season 4 Brooke as much as other seasons, but I also don't think it's her worst season. Brooke seemed kind of lost and unlike herself in season 4. I like that she's more sassy & feisty in season 4 than in season 6, but she also had many more mellow & depressing moments than the first 3 seasons. There are some season 4 Brooke scenes I really loved, but overall I wasn't so interested in her story lines. So much of season 4 Brooke felt like she was either bitchy b/c she was hurting or mellow b/c she was hurting... but not so much else.