Definitely season 2, it drained my hopes for Leyton but season 3 regained my hopes for them. ;)

I hate season 2
ex:
1- haley leaves on tour and nathan becomes a mess and eventually there marriage goes to the dumps
2- anna
3- felix
4- no leyton whatsoever.
:'(

^it was pretty bad, for all of those reasons,
but i still liked it, even a little,
just because it IS one tree hill!

I think i am the only one who actually liked season 2 but i hated Season 4 it had so many bad storylines and my god that hair.

I chose Season 2 because of:
1. Anna [I didn't really like her]
2. Hayley going on tour with Chris and ruining her marriage
3. No Leyton [they belong togther!]
I actually am undecided on putting down Felix for a reason why I hated Season 2. I guess he was okay with Brooke, but the whole Anna storyline [which includes her being with Lucas] was terrible, in my opinion.

first of all Lindsay!!secod of all nanny Carrie ruined Naley,3 rd of all poor Petyton had too much stress,and last on i hated lucas soo much

season 4 had the worst hair and the worst storylines, season 2 was boring.

boring as hell
I guess it's because there was only 4 Leyton scenes

i love season 2...hate season 4

what a joke!

naley =(

i love season 2 even though naley are apart it is a good season. i think that season 5 was not very good not just because of leyton but because of the storylines. oh and too much of jamie.

Season 2 was AMAZING!

- Jeyton
- Brucas
- Naley (In the first 6 episodes)
- Great drama
- No Leyton
- CHRIS KELLER
- The amazing season finale