I loved them in 6x02!!

^^ agreed! thats why i was able to pick. :)

I picked Peyton because they look so much alike.
The picture of Peyton reminds me of Deb in season one.

i don't really love the idea of deb with any of them....but if i had to choose, i did through process of elimination....i think peyton would be too complicated for deb to handle and be a good mother to, and i think haley would be so embarrassed of deb and nothings worse than being embarrassed of your parents....so i guess brooke. even though i like karen and brooke WAYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYY better than deb and brooke.

Brooke, because I love there scenes in season 6, plus I think Brooke and Deb would make a good mother/daughter relationship!

Brooke just because she is the most alike...but Peyton is way too deep to be Deb's daughter. And complicated.

Brooke is kinda like her but Peyton looks like her so I gotta go with peyton.

Brooke is more like Deb,so I can see it. Btw,people remember that Nathan doesn't look like Deb.

^ true that SQ, plus the only reason they made Brooke Brunette and Peyton blond was to fuck with us, and think Dan was Luke and Deb and Karen were like B & P...

Laurencia7 I really don't think that is true, I just don't think he wanted two blondes on the show!