This was pretty hard for me all did so great, but i was tied between Hilarie,Collin and chad...Hilarie was amazing in the first scene where lucas first finds peyt..Collin i think did amazing as well..the way he acted looked so real and he did great! Chad, did great as well..i think he has a good performance..he did great scene will Hil! Also i think sophia did good too, but i just didn't pick her because they weren't that much scenes with her. Anyways Here's my order on who did great!
1.Collin
2.Hilarie
3.Chad

1.Sophia
2.Chad
3.Peyton
4.Haley
5.Nathan

haley & nathan were just WTH
i would say
1. hil
2. collin
3. sophia
4. chad
5. danneel
6. lee
ALL THESE I LOVED =)
oh wait i forgot keith & dan =P

sophia was soooooo good in this episode!!

all of the actors did so great in this episode(Props to the writers too it was a great script)

i thought colin did the best because i think he had the hardest role to play
he really did great and made the audience believe what he was asying

For sure!

They all were amazing, but Collin & Sophia's performances really touched me.