I love her she is my favorite character... she is such a good friend to everyone and she is so independent and amazing and so caring she is just so genuine and she is the most selfless person ever!

well its a quetion so here is an answer: Because she is sluttiest bitch ever...wel she is not bad friend...i dislike her 1-4 season,since season 5 and 6 she is ok for me...but most of the time i hate Brooke

I don´t hate her, I just didn´t like her until this last season. She always liked to play the victim, when in fact she´s kind of a bitch. I have stated my reason SO MANY times, so I´m sorry if this comment is short. Besides, I´m kinda lazy because it´s late.

it's not a rumor believe me we hate her lmao

let's see..she's immature...she's selfish...she's annoying...she likes to act like she's a victim but most of the time what happens to her is her own damn fault...plain and simple she's childish! even now...though she's improved alot she still is...i've never liked her and i never will

omg Janelle is smarty pants..totally agree with her!!all of above what Janelle said is true plus i hate her voice and cant stand her face

I like her but i really don't...depends what mood i'm in! She can be so malicious sometimes and i truely hate that about her. And the self obsession really grates on me too!

I love Brooke, some people just have problems....^^Her voice is amazing and she is very pretty!!!!!

^^What do you mean?

i think i dont have problems...

and she told it to me cause i put that her voice annoing

oh rite i was wondering lol i know what you mean though - sometimes her facial expressions are fucking annoying!

And...actually it really pisses me off how in the show everybody thinks she's amazing and can't stop signing her praises and goes on about how AMAZING she is!WHEN she's nothing special really IMO. That bugs me too no end! Probably another reason i love Peyton as much as i do - she seems to be the only one to ever call Brooke out for things that she's done *ponders* lol weird! Anyway yeh in general i'm pretty sure i pretty much hate/dislike Brooke's character.....hmmmm.

i like her because her friend and boyfriend cheated and she forgave them both and is always there for them! i love her because she is the best god mother someone could have also i relate to her in so many ways! I love her because she has been through so much with her mom leyton the robery and she can still be her cheery fun self shes the only one who brings lightness and fun to the show shes also my favorite character and the most amzing beautiful funny kind and loving character

I know Ive said Peyton is a bitch before LMAO

I totally agree with Meh

I loove Brooke:O She is the best character in the show!!!! I still don't see why people hate her that much?;O

I love brooke...she's the best caracther ever....A lot of people watch One tree hill because of her...I think One tree hill will never be the same with out her...:D

i love brooke in my opinion peyton is the annoying,depressing person to watch at times.i love brooke because she is the only one who actually bring some fun into OTH!

What Sarah said.
It's not her, it's everyone else.

And she just pisses me off!

I don't hate her, she's just rather UGH at times.

Brooke is the best charcter in OTH she is the reason i watch it , if it wasnt for her in season 5 i wud of stoped watchin OTH XD

Sophia Bush/Brooke Davis is gorgeous and her voice is unique and I love it!!! I admit season 1 she wasn't the best she could be and in season 4 she said some hurtful things but overall Brooke is a good person and she has grown in so many ways, all the characters have something about them we don't particullary like so why pick on Brooke?

grr i would kick her ass with pleasure

I don't hate her but I don't love her. I agree with other fans who don't like her,she is sooooo overrated. Almost any fan who loves her,loves Brucas and hates Peyton. Most of these fans act like she's the only important character on OTH. Also,Brooke herself is annoying and bitchy.

I don't know why you created this pick falloutboy...you hate Peyton so you should understand why someone could hate a character,ANY character.

She is THE BEST...I love her!I dont hate anybody but everybody has they oun fans...And this go to all the fans Brooke&Peyton are best friends and they are awesome!!!!!

i love brooke! shes the one with the desency to forgive peyton, TWICE when shit happens. she was ALWYAS there for her, anytime she needed it. she trust peyton to go with lucas in the first season, but obviously peyton couldnt be trusted. she is an amazing friend. she is always there for anyone not just peyton. mouth, lucas, haley, and nathan. she is THE niccest person on the show. she has grown so much. and when does she play the vicitm? what you mean when peyton cries EVERY two seconds, and when shes there for her? right, when she took her shoulerd in season five, right thats SO the vicitm. peyton is the one that CRIES every TWOOOOO seconds. brooke is the best person, good hearted, person on that show. so deal.

I love her.She's my favourite character from OTH...There are so many things I like her for.I agree with Chlarkfan and othluver.I don't hate anybody.In fact I'm kind of Leyton fan (they are meant to be)but I don't like Peyton so much because I am like Peyton (never sure what I want) and I really don't like this part of her character...but still...Leyton is a miracle,they are awesome...

And to those of you who said that Brooke is SELFISH...People,she is everything else but not selfish...

umm hmmm the whole baby adoption thing, as nice as the idea may have been her motive was selfish...when it comes to owen, she was selfish at times in that relationship...or how bout when she threw that party in the school after keith died..you can't tell me that was for Lucas...cuz if it was she's either the dumbest person in the world or she's lying!...umm her whole friends with benefits she had goin on with lucas in the beginning of season 3...she didn't care how he felt about it....or in the beginning of season 1 where she decided she wanted lucas even though she knew quite well that lucas really liked peyton and she knew peyton liked him too...the girl is most definitely selfish...she may not be as selfish as she used to be but she still is.

i guess what i don't understand is why people seem to automatically EXPECT people like Brooke, like it's impossible not to. sure there are times where i've hated all the characters, except LUKE cause he's my favorite...and that's usually how it goes, people have their favorite characters that they love not matter however I think people should also be able to accept that other people may not feel the same about that character...I mean I LOVE LUCAS, he's my favorite always has been...but there are things are his character that i don't like but even more so I can UNDERSTAND why people wouldn't like him....i think people just need to accept that not everyone likes all the naturals.....

well i love B.Davis. and a lot of the reasons people listed for not liking her are some of the exact same reasons others would use for not likeing lets say peyton. i get tht pple dont like brooke, but i for one love her. its just that MOST people do like brooke, thats why i guess some people are surprised that others dont. idk. i just now i love her. best character on the show and the only reason i watch right now :)

oh and chlarkfan, AMEN! lol

omg, i lovelovelove brooke! shes my fav character! and shes waaaaaaaaaaay prettier than peyton for those p sawyer fans! i think peytons the most annoying person on the whole damn show! ive hated her since day one. ive loved brooke since day two since those suckers didnt put her in the first episode! and her voice may hav gotten worse but i think its still pretty. i love wen ppl hav raspy voices. as some of u may know, i seriously hate peyton. shes so annoying and such a whinyass bitch. if u compare her 2 brooke, in my opinion, hands down brooke is bettr. im sorry brooke haters, jus my opinion. but i honestly think the worst characters r the whole "leyton" thing. whoever wrote peytons character, they need to rethink it. yes like the rest of u brooke fans i TOTALLY agree with chlarkfan! well said! yeah i totally undastand that ppl hate certain characters, seventeenqueen. thats exactly y i posted this. so i cood c wut ppl think about brooke lyyk how i xplain y i hate peyton. makes sense rite? -xoxo Dannygirl