এই প্রশ্নের উত্তর দিন

সেভেরাস স্যাপে প্রশ্ন

Don't আপনি think that Snape would have wanted to die after his task was accomplished, so he just let Nagini bite him? (Remember: he wanted to die, but instead decided to help protecting Harry; that was his reason for living...)

 Don't আপনি think that Snape would have wanted to die after his task was accomplished, so he just let Nagini bite him? (Remember: he wanted to die, but instead decided to help protecting Harry; that was his reason for living...)
*
omg such a good প্রশ্ন I understand now why he died because he knew Harry would be ok from there on and after all he ব্যক্ত he could put a stopper in death
snape_always posted বছরখানেক আগে
*
yah i guesss thats why he went wen voldy summoned him otherwise i think he had enough brains to know that voldy wasnt just calling him for a nice little chit-chat ..... still we have to analyze the fact that until then snape hadn't told harry the whole truth abt all that had happened , he had no way of knowing that harry ron n hermione were evesdropping
mmastim posted বছরখানেক আগে
 lilyZ posted বছরখানেক আগে
next question »

সেভেরাস স্যাপে  সর্বশ্রেষ্ঠ উত্তর

snoznoodle said:
I don't think he ever intended to survive. He never cared what people thought, I have a feeling he probably preferred being hated than loved. The only way to clear his name would be to প্রদর্শনী the entire magical world his deep dark secret and I know he is far too proud to ever accept pity from anyone. It's the reason he's never ever told anyone else how much he loved Lily (besides Dumbledore which was necessary), it's the reason he was only willing to প্রদর্শনী Harry as he was dying. I don't think he could stand being celebrated like a hero, maybe because he didn't think he was one? I'm sure he'd prefer this quiet reverence people have for him over something like how they treat Harry.

He must have only lived to protect Harry and once he knew Harry would win, there wasn't any point to his life anymore. I think he was far আরো at peace as he was dying looking into Lily's eyes through Harry than he'd ever been before in his life.

How tragic! Wow I feel like tearing up!
select as best answer
posted বছরখানেক আগে 
*
So true! *passes the tissue box*
Faith-Rulz posted বছরখানেক আগে
*
He's the tragic hero. He would have wished to die as his life has no longer any meaning once Harry had definitively won over Voldemort. Unless another goal was presented to him - like being Hogwarts Headmaster, I could imagine Albus in his portrait telling him 'Severus, আপনি have to protect our youth now, like আপনি protected Harry' with a twinkle in his eyes, আপনি know Albus. But that belongs to fanfiction. Whatever the way he died, he died a meaningful death and this was his only true consolation and redemption in the end.
LadyNottingham posted বছরখানেক আগে
*
I think thats a good piont ladynottingham I think he needing things to keep him going.
kkbb97876 posted বছরখানেক আগে
next question »

উত্তর

bri-marie said:
I actually kind of think he did *sniff*

I can't imagine, after losing the only woman he's ever loved (more than once)and killing his friend/mentor that his life meant very much to him. Dying was probably seen as a relief.
select as best answer
posted বছরখানেক আগে 
BlackHound said:
I just finished re-reading The Deathly Hallows again for about the seventh অথবা eighth time, and I think that the simple fact that the man had his wand in his hand, prepared to defend himself against the Dark Lord, proves he was not ready to die. It also proves Voldemort truly believed Severus was the true Master of the Elder Wand; he used Nagini to kill him, because he could not risk dueling Severus with the wand that had recognized him as Master.

Ollivander would have told Voldemort that much. The Elder Wand (as both Dumbledore and Harry knew, and Harry told Voldemort himself later) the Elder Wand will not attack its own Master.

The fact that Yates & Co. have chosen to depict Voldemort slashing Sev's throat WITH THE ELDER WAND is their way of telling the অনুরাগী that 1) they don't give a damn about certain details, 2) that Severus wasn't the wands Master. Bastards, anyway.

At any rate, আপনি have to remember that when Severus faces the Dark Lord, he hasn't told Harry shit yet, so why would he have welcomed death THEN? It would have been a catastrophic failure on his part. Even after he'd প্রদত্ত Harry the memories, I don't think he wanted to die. I don't think it was in this man's nature to just lay down and accept death, not when there was still battle to be fought, not when Lily's son might still need his help.

Anyway...Chapter 32, page 656, twelfth line down.

"My Lord!" Snape protested, raising his wand.

and then,

The snake's cage was rolling through the air, and before Snape could do anything আরো than yell, it had encased him, head and shoulders, and Voldemort spoke in Parseltongue.

"Kill."


So no, I do not believe Severus Snape wanted to die, especially not when he was prepared to fight for his life.
select as best answer
posted বছরখানেক আগে 
*
Yeah, I think that too. But I came to the conclusion, that he, probably, pretend his death. I read also between the lines, where Snape kicks out Harry of his knowledge and memories like with a door slam. Honestly, Rowling...always told how intelligent and clever he is. He never trusted someone, he has invented a lot of potions and spell, so why the Merlin should he die like a dumbass, knowing his task wasn't fullfilled yet? It's a little ridiculous to me, how the book is written, there are a lot of loopholes. I guess that part with the door slam in the book, reveals that he was not dead, perhaps. He did not want that harry sees that he is still alive. He did precautions, maybe he drunk some healing অথবা resurrection potions which he invented , he is smart enough to know that he walks into death risk as he goes to voldemort. Snape is a great and powerfull wizard, he would never die this way Rowling made us believe. Yes, why has he not defended himself? Cause he eventually wanted to fake his death, to go away...? (sounds like a coward...but it isn't meant that way) ... to left all this sadness behind him? Well, what would Snape do if everyone knows that he has survived? He would never tell his darkest secret to anyone, he is the murderer of Dumbledore, a Death Eater....in the eyes of the wizarding world. He would be sentenced to Azkaban, I don't think he was eager to lead his life in a jail, maybe even sentenced to death. And why was he never mentioned again, a burial অথবা honoured দ্বারা Harry? This social Harry...That's really weird... I mean, there is a man, lies dead অথবা dying in the shrieking shack who has always protected you, fought for you, sacrificed his life for you....and Harry just let him rot like a piece of meat?? He never came back to bury অথবা honor him... he never mentioned Snapes task to his friends. I said, a weird book... no complete conclusion, to many loopholes and so on.... অথবা easily... he wanted to die... but exactly that part of the book, I really can't believe... maybe it is cuz I really hope that he is still alive (in my thoughts he surely is, anyway) ... no one knows the real end... and there's still a secret which Alan and Rowling are keeping about Snape.
SeverusHBPSnape posted বছরখানেক আগে
*
snape wasnt ready to die and he was trying to get his memories to harry before nigini attacked him why do আপনি do think he was pleading wth voldemort to find harry... Because he wanted to tell harry wat he knew!
mvms posted বছরখানেক আগে
*
good point but I think he still could have stopped nagini
snape_always posted বছরখানেক আগে
Faith-Rulz said:
I believe that Snape wanted to die when his childhood love/friend Lilly Potter died but he continued to live to protect her only son, a reminder of Lilly that Snape held onto...

so in some ways did snape want to die after his task was accomplished? and he let nagini bite him? i dont think snape let nagini bite him, i think snape would have preferred to fight out in the open and die with honour and respect he deserved.

but i do believe when he saw harry after nagini bite him and snape was on his deathbed and he passed his knowledge to harry, his mission was accomplished, then yeah he did feel a sense of finality and he died knowing he had achieved his life long goal: protect his childhood friend's son.
select as best answer
posted বছরখানেক আগে 
*
Good answer, I like it. But I still think that Snape shouldn't have let Nagini bite him he deserved another death - as a hero!
lilyZ posted বছরখানেক আগে
*
if snape could have he probably have revealed to voldemorte about his true loyalties before harry could after snape's death (during the confrontation between voldemorte and harry, the latter revealing snapes' loyalties then) and then who knows what would have happened to the story....i also think that snape KNEW that harry and hermione were in the shrieking shack with him and voldemorte and didnt want to risk their revealation before snape could give harry the information that later saved his life in the end....snape's life has been one tragic event after another, its sad, but a marvalous character in all the sense....he's the ultimate anti-hero!
Faith-Rulz posted বছরখানেক আগে
*
aWESOME! I প্রণয় আপনি for these words! And I also think that Snape KNEW that Harry & Hermione were in the Shrieking Shack, I think that he knew even more...
lilyZ posted বছরখানেক আগে
*
who knows how much he did know? but i dont like pplz bashing snape and find his unrequirted প্রণয় for lilly crreepy অথবা whatever. i find his friendship with lilly and his প্রণয় for her pivtoal to his change of character and he never liked to be called a coward দ্বারা harry, sirius অথবা whoever....cuz he's anything BUT a coward, that man scarfriced everything, he হারিয়ে গেছে everything but still he went on
Faith-Rulz posted বছরখানেক আগে
AlexRose123 said:
I think that Snape probably always knew that he was going to die eventually - he lived a life towards the end so full of danger that how could he hope to survive? But the idea that he wanted to die because Lily was dead is incredibly sad and touching to me, but probably true - he fulfilled what he wanted to do, he passed on the information that was intended for harry, but the problem is, Snape thought he was sending Harry to his death. How could he have been satisfied with dying, when the only reason he was still alive (probably) was to protect Lily's son? Also, I think that Snape could have fought with Voldemort if he had tried, he had a wand, and he was probably nearly as skilled as Voldemort. So why didnt he try to defend himself, when his task of protecting Harry wasn't complete?
select as best answer
posted বছরখানেক আগে 
teeheelolz said:
Well obviously poor Snape was depressed but he swore to protect Harry for Lily. He could have killed himself at anytime but he choose not to, with being the most hated person at Hogwarts and living under the pressure of being a double agent for the most sadistic wizard on Earth, can take a toll on a person. But in the book he was so shocked and appalled when Voldermort ordered Nagini to kill him. I think he wasn't ready to die just then and if he had explained himself and got the recognition, respect and honor he deserved he'd have been a little happier.
select as best answer
posted বছরখানেক আগে 
kkbb97876 said:
I have though about this before and sure severus had many pionts in his life were he wanted to just give up, but knew he couldn't. I think when Nigini bit him he still had the will to survive because he knew he still had to tell Harry he had to die, nut when he saw Harry and gave him the memory I think he was content. I have wondered what would happen if he had not died and to tell the truth I think that if he found anyone he really cared about I dont think he would have much of a desire to live. I don't think he let Nigini bite him, অথবা that he was exactaly ready to die but I am glade that the last thing he ever saw was Harry/Lily's eyes Im also glade Harry reconized that Severus was a hero and named his son after him. That was a part of him can live on.
select as best answer
posted বছরখানেক আগে 
snapeinmymind said:
I don't think that he wanted to die. Not at this time of his life. He wanted it earlier, in my opinion, as lily died. Even when I remember the scene in the film when he pleaded Dumbledore to NOT kill him (I hope, I got that right), I think that he somehow wanted it as he noticed that lily was dead. Than he got a new mission, he became Dumbledores spy and protected Harry. So the moment, when Nagini bit him, was not the right moment for him to die. I think that he would have wanted to wait until Voldemort was dead. He must have become sure that it's over with him before he could die himself (sorry for my english, I'm not sure if আপনি can understand this...).
select as best answer
posted বছরখানেক আগে 
*
Perfect. :)
BlackHound posted বছরখানেক আগে
*
Thanks, I was worried about that. আপনি are always very friendly :)
snapeinmymind posted বছরখানেক আগে
snape_always said:
that is exactly what I thought I'd it wasn't for harry I think he would have committed suicide but he knew he had to protect harry but when nagini was biting him he knew Harry was ok so he didn't save himself after all he stayed draco and he ব্যক্ত he could even put a stopper in death
select as best answer
 that is exactly what I thought I'd it wasn't for harry I think he would have committed suicide but he knew he had to protect harry but when nagini was biting him he knew Harry was ok so he didn't save himself after all he stayed draco and he ব্যক্ত he could even put a stopper in death
posted বছরখানেক আগে 
The10thDoctorDT said:
I think he wanted to die to যোগদান his beloved Lily Potter, knowing that her son is going he survive and remember him. And he knew that following Voldemort will soon enough be killed.
select as best answer
posted বছরখানেক আগে 
next question »