I have a nine বছর old sister who followed me in my twilight obsession. now she wants to read the books. should i let her??? (i'm not letting her read breaking dawn for a while, it will take her some time to even fisish the books.)

Okay. Fact one. Kids these days know everything, its harder to keep their eyes shut on subjects like these when the media and social acquaintances influence so much. She might not know the whole deal but she has an idea. Fact two. Breaking dawn is a book that can't be actually considered "rated r" because their isn't really a sexual scene described in it but the fact that it leaves what happens in Bella & Edwards honeymoon in blurry/blank/mystery mode, makes it even worse, because it lets the reader wonder.....a lot. Yea and I would tell আপনি about what went through my mind, ayeee mate, how steamy it might have been..ayee..especially when Bella wakes up with all those damn freaky bruises alright, and then her addiction to it... But the issue might not be completely about sexual intercourse, because depending on how much your sister is at a পাঠ করা level, she might not completely understand at the moment what really is going on. Fact three.What could really be the issue is the excrutiating lovely and bloody gruesome details on bella's pregnancy, because there isn't any blurring out there, everything is well explained and livid and harsh. I believe the most mature thing আপনি could do in your situation and being a sister myself, disregarding the time it might take for your young sister to finally read through all those বই and the boring parts and debating whether অথবা not shes team jacob অথবা team edward...and whether অথবা not she likes the book অথবা not...well before she gets her hands on breaking dawn just make sure আপনি touch the issue briefly. Besides it will be inevitable to not talk about it at all before breaking dawn because there are parts in the other বই that describe the স্নেহ চুম্বন scenes and what not. I think its best if আপনি dont tell her আপনি aren't going to let her read it right away because trust me kids these days..are just over curious, and if shes determined to finish because she has become a die hard twifanpire, she will find the means to get her hands on breaking dawn....even if it means breaking the law....lol well not to such extremes.

Personally i wouldnt even be worried, because I was stressing about it with my sister and it turns out she says she would burn the বই and watch the movies, because they aren't so good. lol. yes she does have bad taste in literature, she would rather read pictures.

i dont think that আপনি should... yet. আপনি should wait till she hits middle school অথবা at least turns 11. this way itwould be easier for her to understand and she will be able to use context clues bette. idk just mt apinion. but trust me আপনি dnt want her gettn nto all the romance stuff too early

Hmm I don't know. I think Twilight will be fine. Even though Breaking Dawn doesn't acually describe when they're having sex...hmmm, I wouldn't worry about Twilight অথবা New Moon. The স্নেহ চুম্বন in Eclipse might be a little much and the sexuality of Breaking Dawn is debatable. I would let her read Twilight for sure. maybe hold off on the others.

twilight mayb new moon not eclipse অথবা breaking dawn though

my sister is nine and read all the বই even breaking dawn

I wouldn't.

tbf i think nine is too young for the books, but i guess it depends on the person really. but not breaking dawn for a while (: aha

yeah.i would do twilight & new moon.but i would read the book to her.maybe till she hits 10 অথবা 11 she's ready for eclipse & breaking dawn.

my cousin she readsthem and shes only 8 years old

noooooooooooooooooooooooo never in her life!!!!!
should she read them too inaproperit . nice try tho

I don't know. Even Twilight... In the movie they cut out a lot of the sexual tension, but in the book it's very raw, and real. Even though she may not understand it, it might be a bit... I don't know. But, apart from the sexual side of it, there is also James. Because we are all thirteen and over and we know it has a happy ending, I think we tend to forget how scary and disturbing it could be for a nine বছর old. A sadistic vampire who wants to bite a teenage girl and suck her blood, who tortures her first and films her as she tries to escape... to a young person thats probably as freaky as something like rape. And then, though we all probably cheer when Alice rips his head off, for a kid this could be quite disturbing. My ten বছর old sister had nightmares - but she is a woos, so... Still, I dunno. Consider the sexual side AND the violence and sadism though. :)

I think it depends on what shes like, if she can handle it let her read the seires if she cant but still wants to read it read it too her an suger-coat it a lil

My mom has read all the বই before me and my lil sister could read them. So have your mom read all the বই before she can.

I'm not sure if a girl of 9 can understand them, well, maybe Twilight and New Moon, but not Eclipse and Breaking Dawn. আপনি should ask your parents before give her the books, they know your sis better than us.

I think it all depends on how mature she is. But if আপনি don't think she'll understand most of it then there is no point and besides I think she would thank আপনি later when she can actually enjoy the book without thinking of what words mean.

definately dont let her read breaking dawn!!!!

আপনি should let her read the twilight & new moon.but i think u should not let her read eclipse and breaking dawn for now....maybe when she's ten অথবা twelve....maybe she will understand eclipse and breaking dawn in that age....just my opinion.

i think its best that yu wait till she is a little bit older only coz she might be too young to really understand the story line but there are heaps of other twilight things that আপনি can get her into like buy he a নেকলেস from the twilight movie, i even think she is to young yet to watch the movie let alone the books? hmm? so yeah wait till she is about 11 অথবা 12 lol. Good Luck! hope this helped আপনি :P

NO dont let her read them she is too young.

u r totally right to not let your sister read breaking dawn mainly cause its like rated r !!and i think আপনি should your sister read twilight and that is allllllll

I think that breaking dawn is a bit too mature for a 9 বছর old... the movie is ok though.

no not a gud idea she is a little young 2 read it and up there is some stuff in eclipse 2 so ya just not বই that little kids should read. and just cause she like the movie is not a very gud reason there is a lot of stuff lef out in the movie and she most likely wount understand it. just dont. wait till he is about 12 অথবা so

Omg she is only 9!It isn`t i don`t like Twilight অথবা somethin but it is "Young Romance"...In Twilight maybe they haven`t got sex but all the time they KISS!Don`t ley her read 'em sweetie!Listen to me!My bro is 11 and he wanted to read " Harry Potter বই " and i made the mistake to LET him rad My BOOKS!then he almost destroyed 'rm and he read 'em in 1 year..omg..don`t let her coz in ur point i would think that she is TOO YOUNG

im only 11 and ive read the বই three times.




আপনি should let her read twilight and new moon, and wait till shes my age to read the other two.

i don't think that u should let her read the বই at the moment... i mean i find her kind of young to read বই about those subjects...u can let her have them when she's older, e.g. eleven. hope i helped! write me when u decide wat to do!:)

ya u should let her read them i mean she might like them

I think it should be up to your parents/guardian :)

ummmm twilight is fine and so is new moon but eclipse has goriness and breaking dawn has parts when edward and bella,
well they do something its very disturbing 4 a 9 yr old

it depends on how much she knows about life.