Yes both were very unexpected and powerful...but I think I preferred Rosalie's. I think i prefered it because I wasn't expecting it to be as sad as it was...it really did shock me. But both were really good.
I agree, both stories were really powerful but i think i prefer Jaspers... because I honestly did not expect him to have gotten changed like that অথবা have been in wars!! but then it goes on to Alice... so i think i like Jaspers but Rose's was really sad too. I almost cried when i read it :(
Both were really good stories, but I think I like Jasper's because it shows how he met Alice, and I liked the ভ্যাম্পায়ার that he met. But Rosalie's story is really really good too, so I think I might like hers better. It was sooo sad! But I'm glad that she had Emmett now instead of that drunk boyfriend of hers and his jerk friends.
Let me see... I've read Rosalie's story (no exagerations) about fifty times and it makes me just as sad every time. I liked Jasper's but I much prefered Rosalie's, so sad!