Yes both were very unexpected and powerful...but I think I preferred Rosalie's. I think i prefered it because I wasn't expecting it to be as sad as it was...it really did shock me. But both were really good.
I agree, both stories were really powerful but i think i prefer Jaspers... because I honestly did not expect him to have gotten changed like that অথবা have been in wars!! but then it goes on to Alice... so i think i like Jaspers but Rose's was really sad too. I almost cried when i read it :(
Both were really good stories, but I think I like Jasper's because it shows how he met Alice, and I liked the ভ্যাম্পায়ার that he met. But Rosalie's story is really really good too, so I think I might like hers better. It was sooo sad! But I'm glad that she had Emmett now instead of that drunk boyfriend of hers and his jerk friends.