|
mandapanda said:
Good question. I haven't heard this one in a while. There may be some little things about her character that I would change, but nothing significant enough to point out. However, I would change what she did in the books. Everything is fine until Eclipse. I thought everything she did in New Moon was in character. She was determined in Twilight. Even though Edward was gone [in New Moon], Bella still had determination. Determination to see Edward and hear Edward and know that he did exist and he wasn't just a figment of her imagination. In Eclipse, there is ব্যক্ত to be a প্রণয় ত্রিভুজ between her, Edward, and Jacob. However, it honestly came out of no where. For the first two books, she's been saying how much she loves Edward and how devoted she is to him. In Eclipse, everything remains the same. Jacob forces himself on her, she pushes him away... until chapter 23. I'll try to explain this as carefully, delicately, and less-confusing as I can. Jacob kisses her. And, she "magically" realizes that she loves him too. Despite the fact that she loves both Edward and Jacob, she can't live without Edward so she ends up choosing him. I'm sorry, but in the পূর্ববর্তি books, she has been saying she cannot live without him and that she cannot see her with anyone else, yet one চুম্বন in the means to save her best friend from basically committing suicide, she "realizes" that she loves him romantically? I admit. She loves him, but I cannot, CANNOT agree with her romatic প্রণয় for him. Their relationship throughout all the বই have been brother/sisterly. However, that চুম্বন can also signify the moment where she was positive that she could not live without Edward. She saw her life without him and she couldn't live in that reality. Nonetheless, I still didn't like how Stephenie Meyer "established" the প্রণয় triangle. It seems like she just placed it in a যেভাবে খুশী spot to give the অনুরাগী a little mystery. Plus, and this is my belief, আপনি cannot প্রণয় two people. Let me say that again. আপনি cannot প্রণয় two people, when আপনি claimed to প্রণয় someone like Bella claimed to প্রণয় Edward. True love, between mythical creatures অথবা humans, I do not believe আপনি can find that with two people at the same time. The প্রণয় ত্রিভুজ placement in the series made absolutely no sense. I have yet to understand Stephenie Meyer's logic ever since Eclipse was released, nor will I ever. And from Breaking Dawn? That book was a mess in itself. The characters were completely out of canon. Edward was not himself. Alice was definitely not herself. The pregnancy wasn't logical. No where in the পূর্ববর্তি বই had Stephenie Meyer succumb to the mythologies, then in Breaking Dawn, there's a prophecy foretold? Just inconsistencies all over the place. And the imprinting...was a little weird to me, putting it lightly.
|
|