Charlie:D

I like Charlie but Carlisle has done an incredible job keeping this family together(not all on his own though). He treats them like his own and helps them in tough situations. They're all pretty good dads though for hanging in there each with his own challenges. It's good how the Twilight series has shown a decent amount of caring fathers.

i think charlie was too oblivious, and carlisle loves his kids no matter what and always tried to do what was best for them and everone else

I think they are all great dads but I gotta say Carlisle and I agree with Stella_01 and kmasseytl

I they're all great fathers, but I like Carlisle the best,he tries to do the best for everyone in the family...