Robert is Edward. Deal with it. Thanks so much for being nice about your thoughts those!!!

I know what Gerard looks like... I dunno, he's not what came to mind when I thought of Edward. He's a good-looking guy and all, but I don't think he's quite Edward material. I also like Gerard's brother, Mikey. At first I thought of him as Edward (just the way he looks, not sure if Mikey can act that well), but now I'm all for Robert Pattinson.

I think that would be really depressing.... I've seen videos with him in them, and he always kind scared me... he is a LITTLE ceepy.
Anyway, I think Robert is a good guy to play Edward, though no-on could really match most of the images the book gives.