Yes because bella even says that being with jacob wouldve been the way her life wouldve gone without edward
He would have been my soul mate still,” says Bella, “if his claim had not been overshadowed দ্বারা something stronger, something so strong that it could not exist in a rational world.”
this is of course if she wasnt killed দ্বারা tyler অগ্রদূত in the first place
I think he might have had a chance with her, but even if he did have a chance with her, would he have imprinted on her???Or would she have ended up like Leah???
posted বছরখানেক আগে
If Bella wasn't with Edward Renesmee couldn't possibly exist. Therefore, Jacob would either imprint on Bella instead, অথবা it'd be impossible for him to imprint on anyone.
No. Bella wouldn't have been prompted to see Jacob to ask about Edward, and if Bella wasn't with Edward, and he never met her, Bella would have been killed দ্বারা Tyler's van. Without Edward and Bella, I don't think there would be any story.
If Edward had never come back then they might have had a chance... But with Jacob NOT imprinting on Bella, would HE have ever been truly as happy as he could have been?