In new moon when edward is fighting Felix. And demtri is holding alice দ্বারা the throat. Shouldn't alice be able to fight back she jst stood there while the went at it!

I dont think they had 'decided' to fight until it actually happend and Alice had no time to react. My problem with the fight scene was Edward..Emmett complains that Edward doesnt fight fair because he can read their minds and knows their পরবর্তি moves...in the New Moon fight...that whole mind thing wasnt really working for him...he kinda got his butt kicked!

Still...with all its flaws and story breaks..I loved the movie!!

i agree but i mean in all fairness Edward was kinds distracted with the fact that they might kill bella. so i dont blame him for not paying that much attention lol. and i think Alice didnt react beacuse she didnt want to make things worse than they already were. but thats just my opinion.


-Alice Cullen

Yes i totally agree! But Alice knows the Volturi will win if she tried and all of them would die! And she knew if she just stood there what the outcome would be so she chose the best option! option 2

she didnt have time to react to cause they didnt know there was going to be a fight

The one that had her was Demetri, the Volturi's tracker. And he is probably faster than she is. Chances are she wouldn't have gotten far and the other Volturi would have had her as well.

TRUE BUT THEY SAY THAT ALICE IS SMALL AND SHE ISNT MUCH OF A THREAT.. BUT I TOTALLY AGREE WITH THAT STATEMENT!!

It's a movie. There vampires, who gives a shit.

Like Alice ব্যক্ত earlier on in the book, the Volturi will win and that's why she told Jasper not to come along. I'm guessing that she 'saw' the outcome if she fought and she would die অথবা possibly just be hurt and Edward would go crazy and try to avenge her অথবা something and they would all end up dead. অথবা something along those lines but basically, if she fought, the consequences would be disasterous.
And she is one of the best fighters. Remember in Eclipse, she takes on Jasper and he just can't catch her.
Just my opinion.

the volturi ভ্যাম্পায়ার are much stronger and much আরো experienced, if alice had tried to fight back she wouldve probly gotten killed দ্বারা demetri, since hes stronger than alice he couldve jst snapped her neck and shed b dead....