I don't know, but I like them both and I don't think it is right to choose between them either, and that Vanessa and Ashley hating each other thing is just a rumor, Ashley and Vanessa are the best of friends!

^^^^^^^agreed!!

i do not choose between ashley or vanessa in the movie high school musical are gabriella montez my nicest but outside the movie I choose not I find ashley and vanessa all sweety's they are this way lovely and them really a lot of fun with each other I find this not really have been possible vanessa the Vs ashley. ashley am quite really complete and she vanessa of the boy friend's this way if in hsm never them are simply complete good girlfriends .ashley and vanessa for ever

vanessa = more talented, way prettier & better!!!

Ashley<333 liked her ever since i saw her in SL.

I like Vanessa because she is more talented and pretty than Ashley

I prefer Ashley but I love them both so much!lol

its obvious that ashley's better, vanessa's a slut.
no offence to pplz.

i used to like her but after the fotos accident, i dnt like her anymore.

both can sing and act :)

Well from my point of view.....
I think Id have to go with........
Ummmmm.........


I DonT kNOW!
I think they are both cool and stuff

i love ashely and venssa

venssa is all ariht but i like ashely

well h2ogirl4lyf, if you dont like her, then y r u on her spot?

....NEVER KNEW....

Vanessa BY FAR!!!!!!

BB V.

Vanessa.
My idol
Hope to meet her someday.

I love Vanessa! I never really like Ashley. For some reason I hated her when I first saw her. I don't hate her anymore but I don't like her. Some of her songs are good though, I'll admit that

i like ashley
but vanessa is my idol so i pick her

i love Vanessa and i don't like ashley .
Nessa is so much better.

hmmmmmmmm.......

if u talk bout earlier times than vanessa if now than ashley!!

vanessa!!!!!!!!!!!

Go Nessa !! <3
I Dont Like Ashley eww

I like them both and also i hate it when people compare them becuse they are both bueatiful talented girls! (I like Vanessa a tiny bit more though)