never saw sydney white, but i liked didn't like cinderella story at all

what's beastly?

I flove A cinderella story, with my heart. But for some reason, I ended up picking Aquamarine, idk, I like Sara's acting skills more than Hilary's.

yeah, i like a cinderella story too but sara paxton is the better actress and i like aquamarine more. beastly is an upcoming retelling of beauty and the beast in modern day. vanessa hudgens (barf) will be the beauty.

are you serious? vanessa hudgens is gonna be the beauty? OH GOOD GOD, KILL ME NOW.

I haven't seen Aquamarine. I guess I'll go with Hilary Duff in a Cinderella Story. I saw Sydney White once but I don't know.

I'm fine with Vanessa Hudgens being the beauty. I haven't seen a bit of High School Musical but I actually do think she is super cute. Quite pretty.

yeah, i like sara more than hilary and omg vanessa's gonna be beauty? kristin kruek(lana lang) is more fit for that role.

TigerRanma, Vanessa Hudgens is pretty I'll agree with you there. But she is the worst actress in the history of the world.

Haha... I don't know about her being an actress. I never saw any of her movies. XD

LOL I'm agreeing with Mongroose here, Vanessa is adorable looking and all, but god she's such a bad actress xD
Watch Aquamarine, you'll like it :D

I don't like any of these movies, to be honest, lol.

Hilary was good as Cinderella.Sara kinda acted more like Giselle meets abit of Ariel.

never saw any of them
Amanda Bynes shes cute though

here is my opinion

Hilary(Cinderella)- I love Hilary and this movie though I preferred Selena's Another Cinderella Story
Sara(Aquamarine)- I love this move and Sara but it should not be in this question as it was not even a moderen take on Little Mermaid it is its own thing
Amanda(Sydney White)- Again I love Amanda and this movie and seeing as how I was not a big fan of Snow White I much rather preferr this movie
Vanessa(Beastly)- Now I haven't seen this movie yet so I can't really say except that I love Vanessa

LMAO @ mongoose..you crack me up. I thought Hilary Duff was a horrible Cinderella...I loved Aquamarine...never saw Sydney White.

rogueslayer17,
the film version of aquamarine was loosely based on the book with a lot of the little mermaid elements twisted into it:
mermaid turns into human and has three days to make a human guy fall in love with her...that's the plot of both movies.

Never heard of any of them. I just pressed one.

I love Aquamarine