Honestly, I'm not a fan of both. So the decision was difficult. In the last years Depp became some kind of nag for me and so reached a high level of boredom.

By miles & miles!

I agree with Astradyne but I still prefer Depp a lot more. He's a really good actor but all his last movies were big flops.

Both but by far

I like both but I think Johnny is definitely the superior of the two - he's a lot more versatile and I feel he puts more effort into his roles than Orlando. Johnny IS the character, while Orlando just plays the character.