Well, we didn't really get to see Lucas being a father

lucas is a great dad. i wish he was mine.

We got to see so much more of Jake being a father...

I agree with Orsolya. We didn't really get to see Lucas playing a father role so much. Not to mention Sawyer's mom isn't some psycho stalker/bar skank. So Jake def. had to turn up the fatherly role. Which Luke would have had to do if P. Sawyer had died. Which she didn't. Thank, Mark. LOL.

Well we really didn't have the chance to see what kind of a father Lucas is.I'm sure he'd love Sawyer very,very much adn he'd be a great dad.
But Jake,was just Oh my God!He was defintely ready to do anything for Jenny and he did it.He sacrificed his happiness and youth to protect his daughter and give her the best possible.

Exactly what backtoblack said. Jake sacrified EVERYTHIN for her!

jake without a doubt as we saw jake more as a father than luke also we saw him being the protective father which was amazing i wish i have a guy like jake for my children

Both, but i like Lucas more

We never saw Lucas be a dad really, we saw Jake though & he was great -he really loved Jenny, hed do anything for her you can tell. But Lucas was amazing from what the little we did see -and plus remember what hes like with Jamie & With Lily -he's so cute with them -he makes a great dad :)