well of course i like edward better than carlisle but as a father i like carlisle better. billy is one of my least favorite characters, and charlie's pretty much always been ok. not one of my faves but not bad.

^
yeah, but i just can't really picture edward like a dad....

I never really liked Billy. and Carlisle seems like a perfect dad - supportive, carrying, understanding. I think Edward is an awesome dad to Nessie but he is not really a dad type

i definitively want a dad like him

Charlie is kind of stupid if you think about it... my friends and I were talking about him the other morning... GREAT conversation XD XD

I don't know, i've always liked Charlie for some reason.

I love Edward but Charlie is so cute

Edward is such a cute Dad.

cuz he had jake and jake is just DA BOMB!!!!!!! Marry me taylor lautner/jacob black!!!!!

i think carisle is great and by the way charlie is not stupid!!!

and Edward too