read about it here- link

It happens in the book so it should happen in the movie!

It happened in New Moon! The last chapter..
"Marry me first."
"Okay, what's the punch line."
"Y"
our wounding my ego, Bella. I just propsed to you and you think it's a joke."

Anyways... Everything in New Moon, leads up to the proposal. It's *essention* because that is what determines her mortality and that her and Edward would be together forever.

I'm dont get this. The proposal is in New Moon! Bella agrees in Eclipse. I dont see why people are fighting for it to be in Eclipse, because it will be in it. But it also has to be in New Moon. Those are important parts in the book, so the story will work out.
I'm with mandapanda!! She even gave you evidence of the proposal.
P.S - Evka26-vampire you wrote purosing instead of proposing.

he shouldnt get down on one knee with the ring like he does in eclipse it should be the same as in the new moon book

they should switch the books, in new moon he propose to hear, but she thought it was a joke, so in Eclipse it was the real proposol, the one knee thing and the ring. They should keep it till Eclipse :D

THE PROPOSAL IS IN NEW MOON,

i'm glad i got that off my chest x)

cant wait!

He proposes to her in NEW MOON, But I would love to see him get down on his Knee in 'ECLIPSE' slip the ring on her finger..I'll cry for certain. I can't wait to see the relationship between Bella and Jacob grow,(but I'm 'team edward') to set it up for the'ECLIPSE' movie!

mandapanda, I know, that's what I said..

^^I was replying to laureng114's earlier comment. She was a bit confused. But she deleted her earlier comment.

sorry sweet_twilight:D

Ah I see :D

It's okay, I was just a bit confused when I read the question. But I got what it meant, dont worry.

The proposal happens in New Moon...the essential end to determine Bella's greatest wish: to become immortal and be with Edward forever. So, yuppers...it has to be done and sealed in New Moon (the movie). :)

the proposal needs to happen in new moon...it is a big part of new moon and will be a even bigger part in eclipse b/c a lot of edward and bella's conversations r about the proposal. i heard that the proposal will not be in new moon which iam soooooo against b/c it needs to be..XD