For some reason, I just like Esme more than Molly, I like Molly okay (I like HP a lot more than twilight. I like twilight, but I'm not obsessed with it), but Esme just seems gentler.

See, I don;t hate Esme, she is sweet and kind, but we really don't see ,much of her.

Molly on the other hand, we see how much she loves her children and even, Hermione and Harry. She is sweet and VERY motherly, And she can kick-ass!

I would hate haveing Molly as a mum.

Don't get me wrong, I'm Team Potter all they way but I do prefer Esme. Why?

Esme supports her kids. Molly was really disaproving of Fred and George's career choice, she loaths Bill's love and seems to always finds a way to blame poor Ron.

Molly is also really bossy. To her kids, her husband, you name it! I wouldn't want those kind of qualities in a Mum.

Molly also treats her kids (and Harry) like two year olds. I would get really annoyed by that. I like it when people treat me like the age I am.

My mom is a lot like Molly and I love her haha <3

I do like both and find them very cute and caring mothers, but Molly is just my hero.

^^^ agreed

Regardless, My own Mother does just fine.

We barley know about Esme's parenting skills you know but I just don't like Molly by herself but with Arthur.

I'm a hp fanatic,but Molly as mother,no thanks!!!! I hate her for killing Bellatrix,but apart from that i don't really like her as a mother either!!!

*shrugs* she cooks great.

Molly provides the type of parenting I've never needed.

I just find Molly hilarious

We don't really see much of Esme. I think she was too flowery and sweet, like with not enough backbone to discipline a kid.

^agree. and Molly's kids grew up to be wonderful people.

Both are great but Esme's f*cking awesome!

Molly frickin defeated Bellatrix because she almost killed Ginny. If someone tried to kill any of Esme's "children," what would she do? nothing