I've tried to pair up characters with roughly the same number of fans eg Peyton against Haley and Linsay against Carrie(well some people might like her evilness)!

Anyway also this pairing BECAUSE both team members on both teams dislike each other - so you might as well exclude "in fighting" as a factor! =D

AND because there are too many Brucas+Leyton questions so i'm trying fight questions instead!

Comment on why!

Peyton is the toughest chick on the show! Lindsey will just let Peyton do all the fighting anyways, lol.

Okay here's my reasoning: I agree Peyton is, out of the four, the best fighter. I also agree that, despite her saying other wise that Lindsay would be a CRAP fighter! (she did go to an ivy league school! lol no offence!)

BUT i also think that Carrie is crazy - very crazy - so that works in her favour plus she's not a stick either. On top of that Haley has got alot of anger to use at the moment plus, i think she's tougher than she looks!

So while Peyton could take one i don't think she could take two - so i'm on Haley and Carrie's team i'm afraid D=!

> and yeh i know i spelt Lindsey wrong - i'm sorry !!

I m not quite sure because peyton does box but when haley looses it she really looses it

lindsay can take all three of them

peytonhater... have we actually seen Lindsay in an actually fight where she didn't just get her boyfriend to sort it out? Thought not.
But as for the actual fight, I agree with SG1-090

dude like peyton has alreadt been in a fight with nikki she tackled her!! so peyton will win

actually Nikki kicked Peyton's ass in season 1 but that's not the point.
Carrie is soo crazy so i am sure Carrie with Haley would win lol