By far. Team "happy Brooke"! :)

I love both... but it's hard for me to find any couple I love more than Brooke & Lucas. Their passion, chemistry, and "adorable-ness" are pretty much impossible to beat.

But I do love Brooke & Julian as well.

they fucking PWN.

Brucas Forever

They will always be my number 1! ( :
BJu are adorable too though. As long as Brooke's happy...

Team Happy Brooke (:

duhh.

Brucas <3

Brucas.. [L] Brooke will never have that sparkle in her eyes that she had when she was with Lucas.. =) Brooke&Lucas Forever

he didn't break her heart... but Lucas did...

^^ I don't mean this in a rude way, but if you are going to judge a couple based on if they have ever been heart broken from one another-- do you like any OTH couples? Just since both Nathan and Haley have broken each other's hearts (everything with Chris Keller and Carrie), Lucas and Peyton have both broken each other's hearts (Peyton refusing Lucas's marriage proposal, Lucas sleeping with Nikki and getting engaged to Lindsey, Lucas telling Peyton he hates her...), Jake and Peyton broke each other's hearts (Jake leaving Peyton, Peyton admitting to loving Lucas), Brooke and Lucas broke each other's hearts (Brooke sleeping with Chris Keller, Brooke breaking up with Lucas, Lucas kissing Peyton), Brooke broke Julian's heart (breaking up with him, refusing to admit she loved him, distrusting him...), Karen broke Keith's heart, Karen broke Andy's heart.... do you see what I'm saying? I think it's fine to not like Brucas, but if it's because Lucas broke Brooke's heart... then it would be difficult to find any OTH couple in which one person didn't leave the other person heart broken at one point or the other.

I don't get the whole "Happy Brooke" thing. I've barely watched s7/8 but when I do and when I see clips, Brooke's constantly crying...

^ No offense, but I don't really think that's a valid argument. Because if you would actually watch these seasons, you'd see that when she's crying, it's usually NOT because of Julian. It's about OTHER things. Like finding out that she can't have kids, or problems with Victoria, or officially losing her company. She's probably only cried over Julian like... once. Maybe twice.

As opposed to when she was hurt/sad when she was dating Lucas. Those times were ALL strictly about BL, and Brooke's insecurities, and hurt feelings soley involving BL's relationship.

So overall, in terms of RELATIONSHIPS (not seasons)... she's definitely happier with Julian. I don't really see how anyone can deny that. Sorry. Which is where the term "Happy Brooke" comes from!

I used to be a huge Brucas fan but I realized they weren't meant to be. And I really like Julian, he makes her very happy and they are a great couple!

I like Brulian to but they can't compare to Brucas in my book.