I don't know what to think of it actually. I know that i think he is drunk, but it's still stupid to say that to her. As of now i really don't care what happens to LP. I hate that mark makes it sooo freaken hard for them to be together. Now he has some BL "Bones" thrown at us just to make us (LP fans) feel less confident that LP will be end game.

Leytonfan4ever,
as frusterating as leyton is right now, I think i'll appreciate their reunion all the more in the end. I wouldn't worry about BL. They played house for one night and I knew it would rattle the brucas & leyton fans. I think it's just a tactic to keep us on our toes. Leyton is clearly still in love but are once again separated by circumstances. Brucas has given NO indication that they still have feelings for eachother. So till brucas has been doing anything like writing books about eachother, staring deep into eachother's eyes in painful desperation, kissing eachother or getting jealous when they see eachother with other ppl, I choose not to worry and let this play out.
I think if us leyton fans accept that leyton won't be together this season and that we're gonna have to wait, then the frustration'll ease a bit. If peyton can be patient, so can we, heh.

If lundsey broke up and leyton had many romantic (even if non sexual) scenes together that pointed to their eventual renewal, it would be cake for some leyton fans, boredom to others and annoying predictable scenes to non-leyton fans. I think the mystery of "anything is posssible" is mark's goal this season and he is indeed doing a good job of leaving the fans in the dark about what's to happen. part of me likes it that way - cause I think he makes it work/make sense (even if luke's an idiot this season in the process). the leyton fan part of me feels sad for peyton, but i'll always hope for leyton, no matter how grim it looks.

I think Mark'll make leyton's reunion worth the wait. Don't worry :)

Haha yeah i guess i'll be patient for another freaken season..lol It just bothers me that Mark always has to make it hard for LP to be together. I know it's worth the wait, i mean look at 409, but i just think it's unfair that we had to wait for 4 (or 3) seasons just for LP and now that they did happen (in S4) mark brakes them up, and i've been trying to be very patient with this whole LP situation, but it's just super frustrating for me right now. It's probably because i do miss LP, i just want LP back..lol

your frustrations are warranted :)
to be honest, LP's reunion in 4.09 (as happy as I was that they were finally together) wasn't even as great as brucas' in s3 (intense excitement wise). I hope mark makes their reunion more dramatic and meaningful the next time around. half the greatness of leyton is their painful longing for one another when they're apart.
I have a feeling that luke's gonna have to chase after peyton after he drives her away, then Peyton'll eventually give in. but luke's gonna have to do some serious graveling. you know if s6 is coming in the fall? s5's quite short :(

Well that's a first, i thought the LP reunion was great! I wish LP's reunion will be in the rain=)! That would make my day:D! I haven't even watched any of the new episodes, but i've read spoilers and i ain't liking it..lol Anyways i just hope that in S6 there WILL be LP, and i'm gonna say it right now that if mark puts BL back together, which doesn't really make sense, but IF he does then he better make it for real and not make the same "Switch back to peyton" kind of thing. Also the relationship better be better then their friendship, because i think the BL friendship is 10x times better then their relationship. And Luke better treat brooke right...lol

from what i've heard i think he is!

Where's the option for those of us that think its no mistake at all?

Sorry but I'm getting more than a bit tired of people assuming that this is some mistake Lucas makes. It's about damn time!

heartinohio, this question isn't asking if you think luke makes a mistake when he says what he says to peyton. you have the right to your opinion, but this question's asking if you think luke'll be drunk when he says these things to peyton...
I'd be happy to add an option you like if it applies to the question :)

ive heard he is :s - but it will be a huge mistake either way!
this is when he has to start fightin for peyton! be a man luke!

couldnt be arsed readin all what youve put abs - too long - but i want a leyton reunion in the finale of s5! dont care if its crappy - it will be my favourite episode cause there back together at last!

lol, laurra. yeah since SPOILER ALERT*** peyton decides to leave to L.A. in e17, I'm hoping luke will realize the error of his ways and chase after peyton in e18, but it won't be so easy. might be a little cliffhangery...

its not a mistake

definately a mistake and i agree with all the leyton fans...

LEYTON FOREVER

Abs07: I asked "Wheres the option for those of us who dont think its a mistake"

lol sorry but i think its crappy when picks dont have an option for both sides...

^^ Why don't you just chose "Yep. He's gotta be to say something like that to her."?

Because thats still implying that I think its a mistake. I dont!!

heartinohio, again, this pick isn't about choosing if you think he made a mistake...

you can just add your comment with the pick you choose. like what 1treehillfan did.

if hes not drunk then he is an absolute idiot. i mean, even if he's not in love with peyton (which he totally is deep down) i dont believe that he would say that to a friend. he hasn't been the perfect and lovable luke in a while, but i dont think that he's jumped so far away from the caring man he used to be.

dumb asshole