Most CLAMP manga's in general are better then the actual জীবন্ত since usually the anime's adaptions are too rushed not allowing enough time for good character development অথবা not adding enough depth to the plot . অথবা they change too much in the জীবন্ত adaption ruining the actual story অথবা making it very hard and confusing to follow .
In my opinion some CLAMP manga's that are better then the জীবন্ত adaptions :
xxxholic * the জীবন্ত skipped a few important details and made the story line too Watanuki oriented *
Tsubasa : Reservoir Chronicles * They rushed the plot too fast and did not give enough episodes for a magna series that has over 25 বই . I mean নারুত and Fairy Tail are also past 25 বই and have over 200 episodes , 4-5 OVA's , and a movie অথবা two and yet Tsuabsa had only around 50 episodes , 1 OVA , and two চলচ্চিত্র *
Magic Knight Rayearth * the quality of the জীবন্ত was terrible and they did not venture much into character development which is what made the magna an enjoyable read . *
X / 2000 * Terrible জীবন্ত quality and they changed too much of the story making the জীবন্ত it's own version of the magna instead of a proper magna adaption *
Chobits * My only issue with Chobits is that they rushed the story a little bit making the ending of this জীবন্ত a little too obvious and making the জীবন্ত fell like a cliché প্রণয় story *
posted বছরখানেক আগে
IKR!!! Like Tsubasa actually didn't end the series in the anime! XXXHOLiC was long enough to finish the series though... But CLAMP is making a new serialized series of XXXHOLiC too...
Yeah, I have to agree here. With Chobits, they really took out a couple of the sad and/or cute parts as well as the perfect ending that the জাপানি কমিকস মাঙ্গা had.
Clarification. In the English dubbed anyway, they turn Nezumi into ইঁদুর (His name). I felt the জীবন্ত rushed some of the most beautiful and important parts of the manga.
Nezumi means ইঁদুর in Japanese, so it's obvious why they did that. I didn't read the জাপানি কমিকস মাঙ্গা (i dont read জাপানি কমিকস মাঙ্গা anyway) so I don't know about that.
It's a story about a 'perfect' city that isn't so perfect under the surface. A boy, Shion, who grew up in it, naive to it's truths until chance brought he and Nezumi into contact. It's hard to explain in just a few words and give it justice. It is shonen ai ish (The জাপানি কমিকস মাঙ্গা আরো than the জীবন্ত but it's there too) but if you're ok with that, I strongly recommend it.
personally I think the Black Butler জাপানি কমিকস মাঙ্গা is better than the anime.
posted বছরখানেক আগে
This is the only জাপানি কমিকস মাঙ্গা I've read. Although some of arcs had some ideas that were taken from other places, I still (also) think the জাপানি কমিকস মাঙ্গা is better.
Medaka Box, Kindaichi Case Files and Yodemasu yo, Azazel-san. I did not like the জীবন্ত of the series stated above. The জাপানি কমিকস মাঙ্গা are good though.
I always read the জাপানি কমিকস মাঙ্গা before I watch animes, but though I have only watched one episode of the জীবন্ত Fruits Basket, judging from what I've heard it doesn't sound as good as the manga. It missed out loads of characters, many of which played very crucial parts, including one of my favourites, and some aspects of personality seem to have been altered; I asked some Fruits Basket অনুরাগী how they felt about Shigure having a darker side, and they didn't know what I was talking about, having only ever seen Shigure in the anime. The voices also sound a lot different to how I imagined; when I read জাপানি কমিকস মাঙ্গা I tend to be able to 'hear' the characters' voices in my head in a way, so I expected the জীবন্ত voices to be different, but it was mildly disappointing nonetheless in some ways. Maybe that was just me being fussy, but I was somewhat put off watching when I was told that some of my favourite characters were different/not featured in the anime.
Rosario Vampire. The first season of the জীবন্ত was mostly accurate, aside from characters being introduced at different times. Although, the first season of the জাপানি কমিকস মাঙ্গা had way আরো story to it.
The সেকেন্ড season of the জীবন্ত left the জাপানি কমিকস মাঙ্গা behind entirely and turned it into mostly fanservice, while creating it's own half assed story. I don't mind fanservice, but when it get's in the way of the story and character development then it's too much.
All in all the জাপানি কমিকস মাঙ্গা went waaay past the জীবন্ত and it handled character development much better. The poorly done development in the সেকেন্ড season left a bad taste in my mouth. I still liked the anime, but it can't compare to the manga.
